A patient refuses a treatment you believe is essential for their oral health. What do you do?
Whether you understand patient autonomy and can reason through a conflict without steamrolling anyone.
How to structure your answer
- 1Clarify before deciding
- 2Explore their reasoning
- 3Educate without pressure
- 4Respect autonomy
- 5Document and keep the door open
- Ask why first — cost, fear, past trauma, distrust, misinformation are all different problems
- Confirm they understand the consequences of declining
- Offer alternatives, including partial or staged treatment
- Respect a competent adult's refusal and document it
- Make clear they're welcome back
A strong answer
What lands
First thing I’d do is ask why they don’t want the treatment. I assisted for six years and the reason was almost never what I assumed. One man kept refusing a crown and it turned out his brother had died under general anesthesia for something unrelated, so the man was scared of all procedures. So: ask, listen, then explain the specific consequence in plain words, and offer the alternative version if there is one. If he’s a competent adult and still says no, that’s his choice to make, and as health care providers we have to respect autonomy. I reminded him if he changes his mind, we are happy to see him.
Asks why first, finds a reason nobody would have guessed, and respects the answer.
A weak answer
What most people say
I'd explain why the treatment matters, show them the radiograph, and walk them through what happens if the decay keeps going, so they really understand the risk. A lot of the time people say no because nobody has taken the time to explain it in a way that lands. If they still refused after that, I'd respect it, but I'd want to be sure they had the full picture first.
Starts persuading immediately. Not one question gets asked before the explaining begins.
The trap
⚠Jumping straight to convincing them. The interviewer is watching for whether you ask a single question before you start persuading. Everything hinges on that.
Reading it isn't the same as saying it.
Most people can explain a good answer and still fall apart saying one out loud. Admitted asks you all 100 questions in a faculty voice, records you, and scores your pace and filler words.
Try one interview freeGet the guideMore ethics questions
- During a practical exam, you see a classmate cheating. What do you do?Ethics
- A patient clearly needs treatment but can't afford it. How do you handle it?Ethics
- A colleague asks you to sign off on a procedure they didn't actually complete. What do you do?Ethics
- You notice signs that a patient may be a victim of abuse. What's your responsibility?Ethics
- You realize you've made a clinical error that harmed a patient. What do you do?Ethics
- A patient with restorable teeth demands you extract everything and give them dentures. What do you do?Ethics