A 16-year-old patient asks you not to tell their parent something they've disclosed. How do you handle it?
Confidentiality with minors — genuinely complex, jurisdiction-dependent, and a good test of intellectual honesty.
How to structure your answer
- 1Don't promise confidentiality before hearing it
- 2Understand what it is
- 3Apply the actual legal framework
- 4Involve them in any disclosure
- 5Preserve trust
- Never promise blanket confidentiality up front
- Distinguish safety risks from private matters that can be held
- Know minors' confidentiality varies by state and by topic
- If you must disclose, tell the patient first and let them participate
- Prioritize keeping them willing to come back
A strong answer
What lands
I would listen, but I wouldn't promise absolute secrecy before knowing what the student wants to share. I'd explain in age-appropriate language that I respect their privacy, but there are situations involving safety or required reporting when I may need to involve someone else. If a disclosure raised a concern, I'd follow the relevant rules and seek guidance from the appropriate professional. I want a young patient to feel heard without making a promise I can't keep.
Sets the limit before hearing the secret, and keeps the patient heard.
A weak answer
What most people say
I'd tell him that what he says to me stays with me and he can trust me. Teenagers won't tell you anything real if they think it's going straight to a parent, and I'd rather hear the truth so I can actually be useful. If I thought his mom needed to know, I'd work on convincing him to tell her himself.
Promises blanket confidentiality first, which is the trap this question is built on.
The trap
⚠Promising 'of course, I won't tell anyone' before knowing what's coming. It's the instinctive kind answer and it can trap you into either breaking a promise or concealing a danger.
Reading it isn't the same as saying it.
Most people can explain a good answer and still fall apart saying one out loud. Admitted asks you all 100 questions in a faculty voice, records you, and scores your pace and filler words.
Try one interview freeGet the guideMore ethics questions
- A patient refuses a treatment you believe is essential for their oral health. What do you do?Ethics
- During a practical exam, you see a classmate cheating. What do you do?Ethics
- A patient clearly needs treatment but can't afford it. How do you handle it?Ethics
- A colleague asks you to sign off on a procedure they didn't actually complete. What do you do?Ethics
- You notice signs that a patient may be a victim of abuse. What's your responsibility?Ethics
- You realize you've made a clinical error that harmed a patient. What do you do?Ethics